CQ Contest Digest, Volume 80, Issue 23.
"I say great, let them inspect... or watch on my webcams that are already running if they want."
"This is clearly aimed at a few high profile operators who don't give a damn about sportsmanship and will do almost anything to "win." Having this tool at the committee's disposal will hopefully cause those few to begin respecting our sport or go off and do something else."
"But there's even a greater loophole in the new language. Instead of applying to competitors who are "contacted", the rule only applies to wishful thinkers. If you don't wish for a top score, you can't be visited."
"Think about how insane it would appear to anyone unfamiliar with amateur radio if you told him/her that you participate in an annual contest, that is solely a hobby, to obtain a plaque and bragging rights among your peers, but were subject to such scrutiny that you had to agree to
allow a total stranger into your home in order to be observed during the event!"
CQ Contest Digest, Volume 80, Issue 24.
"We in our no-monetary-prize environment are not alone."
"I agree, it's not the Americas Cup but I suggest it is the equivalent. What other competitive event (in Amateur Radio) holds the prestige of the ARRL and CQ dx contests?"
"One of the things that holds contesting back is flagrant cheating by a handful at the tops of the standings, which up until now has gone largely unanswered. I applaud efforts by the sponsor to control that, and by so doing making the results more meaningful."
CQ Contest Digest Volume 80, Issue 25.
"I don't think there's any disconnect in comparing elite amateur athletes of any kind against elite radiosport competitors."
CQ Contest Digest Volume 80, Issue 26.
"Do the 99% of you here honestly believe the committee is going to ask to send an observer to your station? I don't see the hysteria as being warranted."
"I agree that it's not a disconnect to compare Amateur Radio operators with elite amateur athletes - generally the elite spend considerable time and money to be at the top of the "game." And, there's a big temptation in all cases to cheat."
"As a "NON CHEATER", I do not advocate the use of home invasions to satisfy one amateur's need to observe another amateur win a contest fair and square. And, it is MOST CERTAIN, the suspected cheater will never cheat while the inspection is taking place!"
CQ Contest Digest Volume 80, Issue 27.
"Open logs AND live station inspections are BOTH part of the same course of direction being taken by the CQWW contest committee to quell suspicions of cheating."
"Personally, I think there is that much cheating going on, and I welcome station inspections and open logs."
CQ Contest Digest Volume 80, Issue 28.
"I personally doubt that it will affect the participation [sic. Rule Change] in any significant way."
"If you want a seat at the big table then you have to play by the rules."
"Take a deep breath guys, there isn't a "Contest SWAT Team"."
"[W]e do it (most of us) to have fun and maybe have a chance at winning."
CQ Contest Digest, Volume 80, Issue 29.
"It is up to us to establish a radiosport culture that does not reward or accept cheating, celebrating instead competition on its merits."
Note: I must sustain the highest level of competitive ethical conduct when engaging in RadioSport activities that is personal leadership in my shack.
73 from the shackadelic.