What is there not to understand when RadioSport DX means RadioSport DX only? The spirit of the rules, any rules for that matter, suggest prescribed expectations, a specific set of standards, and conduct of one's operation. When, in the rules of any given contest, its objective is clearly stated.
2009 ARRL International DX Contest.
- "1.1. W/VE amateurs work as many amateur stations in as many DXCC countries of the world as possible on 160, 80, 40, 20, 15, and 10 meter bands." (reference link)
Our first stated sentence clearly spells out the objective. We must work as many amateur stations in as many countries, other than our own, on as many possible spectrum spaces. One might conclude the debate but it does not end on line one. Others, within our RadioSport community, suggest logging other W/VE stations contrary to the spirit of the sponsor's rules.
I do not agree with logging other W/VE stations during a DX RadioSport event especially when our objective is clearly noted. The lions share of this burden would fall on competitive multi-multi stations, single-operator 2 radio(s), and multi-singles.
I, for one believe that any dilution of the rules of competition would --
- Diminish the spirit of competition.
- Foster stagnation of station innovation.
- Enable an entitlement attitude.
- Promote second rate growth within our RadioSport community.
What about raising the bar for our casual operator instead of lowering the bar? I understand, our counter argument, that our casual operator is the bread and butter of RadioSport. That saying '
no' on this occasion may damage future opportunity when invoking our Amateur code.
Friendly.
- [S]low and patient operating when requested; friendly advice and counsel to the beginner; kindly assistance, cooperation and consideration for the interests of others. These are the hallmarks of the amateur spirit.
The first step in any competitive sport is understanding the rules. Perhaps, we might improve how we promote the game and, not take for granted that everyone understands the rules. For me, friendly advice and counsel to the beginner is defined as; not enabling substandard operating practices for example, a RadioSport DX event means RadioSport DX-only when otherwise not stated. Anything less would diminish the spirit of amateur radio competition.
I arrive back at my point, "Easy is easy but adversity defines."
On the other hand, for me, RadioSport is competition where technology meets humanity. I believe, when we raise the bar, those who are earnest will follow, those who do not are least likely to bring innovation into their station. We would, in effect, deny that operator an opportunity at experiencing one of the pinnacles of a RadioSport DX event. On the other hand, we would burden those who engineered, innovated, toiled, and sacrificed to achieve their goal.
We must not open our logs to everyone during a RadioSport DX event. Our rules are implicit when RadioSport DX means RadioSport DX-only. We can better promote the strategic health of RadioSport by not lowering the bar, extend our hands toward the innovator, and offer productive guidance to our beginners.
Contest on.